Best Winter Coats for Women

December 13, 2023

And Other Stories Coat Jenni Kayne Alpaca Sweater Inez Boots Fall Outfit

After twelve years of living in New York City, I have amassed quite the collection of coats. Coats are my favorite way to make a statement with my outfits during November through at least March when we experience Winter Weather in the Northeast. So today I have fully updated my roundup of the best winter coats for women to add variety to your wardrobe but also ensure you have a winter coat for every occasion.

I think the right coat with the right outfit is the best way to look put together and stylish instead of looking frumpy or just wearing any old coat to top an outfit in Fall and Winter. So building out a wardrobe of timeless and practical coats will make winter a bit more enjoyable and getting dressed during the cold months that much easier.

When shopping for coats I personally look for things like versatility (can I wear it several ways? will I get a lot of use out of it?), comfort (always key when I am buying pieces), warmth and of course practicality. I want my coats to be well made and be able to really work for me. That’s why I’ve culled together a list of what I think are the best Winter coats for women to own in their wardrobes. I hope you’ll find this post a helpful resource as you build out your own coat closet no matter what types of Winter weather you may endure where you live.

Best Winter Coats for Women

Sarah Flint Natalie Bow Flat in Nude I wit & whimsy

Classic Overcoat

A timeless style that will never be dated – the overcoat. This is a personal favorite style of coat for me in the Winter as it can be dressed up or dressed down thanks to its timeless and classic wool. I am wearing the Everlane Overcoat above in a size 2 from 2019. Here is the current version of it.

If you like a bit more menswear vibe from your overcoat, I recommend the J.Crew Double Breasted Jacket. Abercrombie has a similar Topcoat style, too.

Holiday Outfits with J.Crew

The Long Streamlined Coat

I love a long almost to the ground coat as I think it just looks so chic – either dressed up or dressed down as seen in the two examples above. 

The top coat is from Massimo Dutti in 2022 and the second is a style by J.Crew (wearing a size 6 but it runs a bit big FYI). This style is also similar as is this one.

Sezane Fall Collection I wit & whimsy

The Lighter-Weight Winter Jacket

If you live in a climate that never gets too, too cold – a classic car coat like this Sezane Johnson Coat is perfect for you. It has a nice weight to it but doesn’t provide too much warmth.

I wear a coat of this shorter length most of Fall and on warmer days in the Winter. It has such a stylish fit ensuring it’ll never go out of style. I size up in Sezane coats and am wearing this in US 8 / FR40.

This coat from Abercrombie is a similar style for a bit less and so is the J.Crew Daphne coat (seen on below in size 6):

Wide Leg Corduroy Pants I wit & whimsy

Sezane James Coat

The Blazer Coat

A blazer but make it a coat! This Sezane James Coat always gets wear in the Fall months for me. I love the exaggerated lapel, the extra length on it and the weight of the material. Such a chic silhouette and a bit more stylish than a traditional peacoat. Would be a great Winter coat for those of you in warmer climates as well.

Wearing size 6. Additional colors/patterns available.

The Curated Camel Wrap Coat

The Wrap Coat

A wrap coat in a beautiful, high quality fabric like cashmere should be in every woman’s wardrobe. The above wrap coat is from The Curated which is a small, female owned business who makes timeless staples for your wardrobe. 

I’m wearing size M. I particularly love how this coat looks beautiful worn both opened or closed. The quality is really good and the brand makes a variety of other beautiful pieces, too.

Club Monaco sells a similar style (and one with a hood!), as does Mango and so does Sezane as seen below in size 6:

Sezane Navy Coat La Ligne Striped Sweater Inez Boots London Outfit Fall

I also really like the wider sleeves on this Mango wrap coat – so chic.

I also own a similar style by & Other Stories (size S- it runs big!)

& Other Stories Wrap Coat

And Other Stories Coat Jenni Kayne Alpaca Sweater Inez Boots Fall Outfit

The Tailored Oversized Coat

This silhouette is a favorite of mine. And this & Other Stories Coat is so good I own it in three colors. Hands down my most worn coat of winter.

I sized down to a size Small which still retains the oversized fit and feel without overwhelming my frame.

Abercrombie has a similar style, too. As does Mango.

Sezane Leo Coat

The Cropped Oversized Coat

One of my most worn coats once a chill hits the air. I love this oversized Leo Coat from Sezane for an instant cool girl factor to pretty much any outfit. It also looks really chic paired with my favorite athleisure looks and gets a lot of wear that way, too.

I like this similar style by Club Monaco, too.

Classic Camel Coat I wit & whimsy

The Shawl Coat

Perfectly slouchy, perfectly drapey and so easy to throw on and look instantly more pulled together- the shawl coat is where it is at. My favorite of the moment is this Double Face gorgeously tailored Eileen Fisher Coat. I sized down to a S.

Athleisure Capsule Wardrobe for Winter

The Sporty Puffer

I wear and layer a puffer jacket throughout Winter. It is my go-to when heading to workouts, hikes or long walks on less frigid days and I love that the Amazon Essentials one I’m wearing here can be easily packed into a small carrying case for being portable. It is also wind resistant. I wear a M. 

For an investment option with a water-repellent shell, check out this Lululemon puffer jacket.

Winter Neutrals I Teddy coat I wit & whimsy

The Teddy Faux Shearling Coat

Cozy sherpa right this way! I’ve had my teddy coat from Emerson Fry for sevearal years now and it is the coziest. This style from Mango with toggles is super chic, too. The black version is on my wish list.

I also own this Teddy Coat from Amazon in a black in a size Small.

Also loving this gorgeous chocolate brown one

Berkshires Fall Travel Guide

The Quilted Liner Coat

If you live in a climate where it never really gets that cold – a quilted liner coat is kind of the perfect piece for you. I wear mine in the Fall but because my Amazon one (above – size M) is reversible the sherpa side is also ideal for Winter for warmer climates. 

I also love the Everlane Quilted Liner Coat.

Coat & Cashmere Recommendations | Plaid Coat and Cashmere Sweater I wit & whimsy

The Plaid Coat

If you’re like me and have a wardrobe largely made up of neutrals, a plaid coat is such a great topper. I particularly love it in a more timeless silhouette that hits below the knee like the Abercrombie “Dad Coat” I am wearing above in a size Medium. 

I typically find a lot of great plaid coats at Zara each season, too.

Classic Topcoat

The Double Breasted Topcoat

A must-have in my wardrobe is a classic Double Breasted Topcoat. Slim in its tailoring and usually in a wool, this is the perfect chic topper to elevate any outfit. Above I’m wearing an Ann Taylor Coat in size Small.

J.Crew has a similar top coat style as does Club Monaco. And this Mango one looks nearly identical to mine.

Fall Capsule Collection with M.M.LaFleur

The Roomier Topper

Ideal for layering or if you need a bump friendly coat, I love a coat in this style that’s roomy through the hips. The M.M.LaFleur Kasha Coat is an ideal neutral for wear and it is light enough and slim enough to pack well for winter trips.

Use code WIT&WHIMSY20 for 20% off your first M.M.LaFleur order (full price items only).

Best Winter Coats for Women

The Dress Up Coat

For those dressier occasions in Winter a timeless structured wool coat that hits below the knee is perfect. I’m wearing the Club Monaco Daylina Coat that’s been a best seller for nearly five years now in size Medium. I love this similar style.

Leather Trimmed Club Monaco Coat on Meghan Donovan of wit & whimsy

The Details Coat

If you’re someone who loves a coat with a bit of pizazz, I recommend this leather trimmed coat from Club Monaco. I’ve had mine for over four years and it is great for dressier occasions but I also wear it often styled more casually as seen above.

You could also do a faux fur collar moment as another style option.

The Reversible Coat

We love a two for one piece don’t we? This reversible coat is half suede, half shearling and comes in five colors.

I also have the below coat that I love has shearling on one side and a chic green quilt on the other. Wearing a size M. Also comes in navy blue.

Finger Lakes Travel Guide

The White Coat

Ok, obviously not the most practical choice of coat but there’s something I love about a white coat in winter – particularly with holiday looks.

Abercrombie has a beautiful looking one right now, too.


Best Coats for Women

The Practical Puffer Coat

And of course I had to include a practical puffer coat. This is the insulated coat I pull out on the coldest days when nothing else will do and it has always helped me when I needed to stay warm. I am wearing the Everlane Re:New Parka that’s equal parts sporty and stylish and keeps me warm even in frigid temperatures.

This coat is comprised of 100% recycled down insulation (instead of synthetic insulation) so it really does help with body heat and I love that it doesn’t add loads of weight to your frame like many other puffer coats. Rather it looks streamlined over any outfit. It also features a water-resistant finish, a snorkel hood, fleece-lined hand pockets to keep your hands warm, and internal sleeve cuffs.

It’s a great puffer coat and perfect for cold weather while also being a far better price point to a Canada Goose coat. Wearing a size Medium. 

If you prefer more of a sleeping bag type style for extra warmth against cold air, check the widget below where I’ve curated additional styles. 

. . .
Shop My Coats
Even More Winter Coats I Love


I have a few places I always look for coats at. They include & Other Stories, Ann Taylor, H&M, Mango, Club Monaco, Everlane, Abercrombie, Sezane, Zara and J.Crew.

Do you have a favorite style?!

You May Also Like:

This post contains affiliate links. Should you purchase something from an affiliate link, I may earn commission, at no cost to you. Thank you for your support of my work!

comments +

  1. Christine says:

    You have the most beautiful coats!! Love it!!

  2. Ashley says:

    Love this post! So many beauties!! Wondering about the sizing of the Sezane Johnson. Did you find that it runs true to size? Thank you!

  3. Lauren says:

    I always find these posts so helpful. Thank you so much for sharing! Do you have a top 3 of coats that you find yourself reaching for the most?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *